Shark Tank
congress

By Their Votes Ye Shall Know Them, Mid Term 2013 Edition

congress

By GEORGE BLUMEL

The 27-member Florida congressional delegation consists of 17 Republicans and 10 Democrats.   Our goal is to build awareness for how your reps vote so constituents can make an informed choice instead of just voting a face or a party. And, being informed, voters can hold their representatives feet to the fire when they find their votes objectionable.  By following these and other rating organizations one can find similar comparisons for all other states.

Congress is in recess now and most of our reliable rating agencies, except for Heritage Action for America, won’t be reporting scores until the end of the session.*see below for current vote info. Heritage Action rates from a conservative view which is instructive to liberals as well as conservatives –a positive SCORE for conservatives can usually be considered negative for liberals and vice versa.

Conservative scorecard:  Many of Heritage Action’s Republican readers are expressing on twitter and elsewhere that they are appalled at Heritage Action for publishing the mid-term Republican voting records that look more like those of liberal Democrats than conservative Republicans. That gives ammo to potential primary challengers – something that does not make the establishment happy. . (We think their angst should be directed at the ones who cast the vote and not at the messenger.)  But the votes don’t lie.

All eleven Democrats are at the bottom of the Heritage ratings with 0% for Sen. Nelson to a high of 23% for Rep. Grayson.  A couple of Republicans are right down there with the Dems: Diaz-Balart at 26% and Ros-lehtinen at 29%. First termers DeSantis and Radel are the most consistent conservatives at 95% and 90%.  Rubio slipped a bit to a still respectable 84% conservative.   For complete standings and key votes go to  Heritage.org.



Most members of congress are now career politicians for whom getting reelected is their primary goal. My representative Lois Frankel is in her first term after many years in the state legislature and city political positions. So far, the bulk of her mailings and emails I receive are requests for money.  I could not find one mention of the deficit that her votes are loading on the backs of our children and grandchildren a la Greece and other welfare states.  Not one mention about the administration scandals rocking the nation.

Not one mention of the regulations strangling our economy.  Look at how your representatives vote, that will tell you what they are doing for –or to– the country. If we had term limits on congress much less time of our elected reps would be spent on hustling cash for reelections. See the petition at Term Limits.org.

Over time, we’ve noticed that many Republicans generally vote more conservative in their first terms and then gradually drift into supporting greater deficit spending on programs that can usually be seen as “going along to get along,” or buying votes to insure reelection.

Since the disappearance of “Blue Dogs” who were the more moderate Democrats of a bygone era, virtually all Democrats nowfollow the big government party line.  Republican platforms espouse limited government, lower taxes, free markets, the rule of law, a strong defense, immigration reform (beginning with secure borders), support of Israel, the sanctity of life and other worthy goals which, to too many, are only platitudes.

The Democrat platform emphasizes government control of healthcare, higher taxes for wealthredistribution, union support, pro-abortion, gay marriage, immigration reform (amnesty), government support of the arts and gun control.  Sadly, there’s very little agreement between the parties nowadays.

Liberal scorecard:  Americans for Democratic Action –Since ADA’s founding in 1947, the Annual Voting Records have served as the standard measure of progressive liberalism. Combining 20 key votes on a wide range of social and economic issues, both domestic and international, the Liberal Quotient (LQ) provides a basic overall picture of an elected official’s political position. – See more 

Non-Partisan scorecards:  Citizens Against Government Waste, National Taxpayers Union and The Club for Growth have not published their 2013 scorecards yet. For our previous report through 2012, click here.

 The Club for Growth published a “spending cut score” that unfortunately only goes up to July 2012 but it is revealing. There were 45 votes on amendments offered in the House to cut spending.  Click here to see a description of each vote.  The Club for Growth position is a “YES” on each of these 45 votes.  The overall score for each Member is listed below.  Some Members were not present for each vote, so a ratio of their YES votes compared to the total number of votes they cast are listed in the % column.



One expects Democrats to vote for few, if any, spending or tax cuts but look at the big-spending Republicans here. They say what you want to hear but does the rhetoric match their voting records?  Would voters hearing Allen West or Daniel Webster on the stump, for example, expect that he would vote against spending cuts almost half the time? Or, that Anders Crenshaw would vote against spending cuts almost all the time? That is the value of these scorecards, to get to know what they are really doing.

 

 FL 19 D Deutch

5%

2 / 44

 FL 21 R DiazBalart

7%

3 / 45

 FL 25 R Rivera

7%

3 / 45

 FL 18 R RosLehtinen

7%

3 / 45

 FL 23 D Hastings, A.

7%

3 / 45

 FL 8 R Webster

60%

27 / 45

 FL 22 R West, A.

60%

27 / 45

 FL 14 R Mack

96%

25 / 26

 FL 1 R Miller, J.

95%

41 / 43

 FL 24 R Adams

93%

42 / 45

 FL 6 R Stearns

100%

45 / 45

 FL 15 R Posey

87%

39 / 45

 FL 16 R Rooney

89%

40 / 45

 FL 12 R Ross, D.

89%

40 / 45

 FL 7 R Mica

80%

36 / 45

 FL 9 R Bilirakis

73%

30 / 41

 FL 10 R Young, C.W.

70%

30 / 43

 FL 5 R Nugent

73%

33 / 45

 FL 2 R Southerland

80%

36 / 45

 FL 13 R Buchanan

76%

34 / 45

 FL 3 D Brown, C.

0%

0 / 45

 FL 17 D Wilson, F.

0%

0 / 44

 FL 11 D Castor

2%

1 / 45

 FL 4 R Crenshaw

4%

2 / 45


*Here’s a great service for tracking  your represntative’s votes as they happen:  http://www.congress.org/congressorg/mlm/signup/

 “Like and share” the story. Tell us what you think, leave a comment below  



About author

Javier Manjarres

As the managing editor of The Shark Tank, Javier was awarded the 2011 CPAC Blogger of the Year. Countless videos and articles from the Shark Tank have been featured on Fox News, The Hill, Wall Street Journal, and other national news publications. Javier has also appeared on Univision’s “Al Punto” and numerous radio shows, including being the weekly 92.5 Fox News' DayBreak with Drew Steele political contributor, as well as one of NewsmaxTV's conservative commentators.

Related Articles

Leave a Comment

  • Tom

    Crenshaw the proverbial RINO big spender liberal. He is no more than negligibly better than the liberal democrat Brown from the 3rd district. Actually they make a great pair.
    But somehow the conservatives in Jacksonville have not been able to figure that out and keep sending him back to DC. I hope the tea party puts up a true conservative to primary him. Good riddance I say.

    • http://www.posterchildrenfortermlimits.com George Blumel

      http://tinyurl.com/mwe42lp Roll Call article about Crenshaw as part of an “obscure caucus.”

      If any Republican congress-critter could ever be called a RINO (Republican In Name Only) Crenshaw is it. Conservative Heritage Action Scorecard shows his voting record is very close to the Democrat voting pattern. He is one reason we suffer from a $17 trillion debt. The Club for Growth showed that of the 45 votes in congress to cut spending, Crenshaw voted against 41 of them!
      He gets reelected by keeping a low profile and talking a conservative Repub game in public. Low information voters don’t look up voting records and have no clue how their reps vote. That needs to change.

  • Pingback: Mid-Term 2013 Congressional Scorecard | American Clarion()

  • Perseids

    It is amusing when those protectors of the ruling class become outraged by the reporting of actual voting records. Better were the days when the bumpkins back home remained blissfully ignorant. Everyone was happy.
    If New Orleans is thy Big Easy then D C has to be the Big Sleazy.

    • http://deepfriedmanates.blogspot.com Carolyn Tackett

      I wonder how many of the ruling class long for the days before the internet? Back in the day a politician could vote anyway they wished and no one was the wiser. Well, tough nookies! As Conservatives we take our responsiblity to be informed voters seriously.

      I have the great misfortune to live in Kathy Castor’s congressional district. Not only am I saddled with a terrible congresswoman but the local Republican party is a joke. I personally heard the former Chairwoman of the Hillsborough County Republican Executive Committee, Deborah Cox-Roush, say at a meeting that the local Republican party doesn’t “waste” its efforts on defeating Castor because “it can’t be done”. Well, no, not with that attitude it can’t. Personally, I don’t wish to be associated with anyone or group that admits defeat before the fight has even been engaged. Looking at the chart above tells the story of Kathy Castor.

      I get so angry at the local party Republicans it makes my stomach hurt. Bottom line is that they are just too lazy to mount any kind of effort.

      • http://www.posterchildrenfortermlimits.com George Blumel

        Carolyn, We had a similarly weak local Palm Bch Cty party about 10 years ago but a small group of solid conservatives worked hard recruiting conservatives and libertarians to the REC and challenged the leadership aggressively and today we’re more than 50% solid conservative. Like everything else, it takes hard work and determination.

        I feel your pain having Castor as your rep. –mine is Lois Frankel — it doesn’t get much worse than those two.

  • Sally Gillies

    Outstanding information for those who like to make informed decisions. Finally, we have a report on what our elected officials are doing which is not necessarily what they are telling us.

    Thanks for the effort it took it put this together. I hope it’s the first of many!

  • rinohunter

    I know he is not a congressman ,but I will never vote for rubio again when he is up for re election, I hope Allen West runs against him

    • http://www.posterchildrenfortermlimits.com George Blumel

      rinohunter: Rubio is is a member of the Senate which is part of the congress. The very first sentence in the Constitution Article 1. Section. 1. All legislative Powers herein granted shall be vested in Congress of United States, which shall consist of a Senate and House of Representatives.
      If you call Rubio a RINO then you are not familiar with his voting record; if you think West is more conservative then you are definitely not familiar with his record.
      The reason I write these articles with links to factual information is so that you will be informed and not be fooled by a pol’s rhetoric.